FORT LAUDERDALE – Family members from three of Parkland school shooter Nikolas Cruz’s 17 victims gave heartrending testimony Monday about how their 2018 deaths at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School have affected their lives, detailing lost loves, lost moments, and even fading memories.
The sister of student Joaquin Oliver glared at Cruz as she left the witness stand, while the families of student Alaina Petty and teacher Scott Beigel appeared to look away from him. Cruz sat at the defense table, mostly looking down but sometimes glancing at the video screen in front of him.
Fred Guttenberg and his wife, who lost their 14-year-old daughter Jaime in the attack, said they are scheduled to take the stand on Tuesday afternoon.
Patricia Oliver, Joaquin’s mother, told the seven-man, five-woman jury and their 10 alternates that he was a gentle and kind boy, 17 and a senior with plans to attend college so he could work in sports management. He was already planning his wardrobe for his graduation three months away, down to what belt he would wear. She said there was an outpouring of love after his death.
“I never knew he had so many friends,” she said, stifling her tears. “Our life has been shattered and changed forever.”
His older sister, Andrea Ghersi, spoke of how when she has children she will have to explain to them why they don’t have an uncle. Hatred filled her face as she glared at Cruz while walking back to her seat.
Oliver’s girlfriend Victoria Gonzalez brought at least one juror to tears as she talked about losing her “soulmate.” She talked about their love of movies, how he would sing along to the car radio and how he met her at the bus stop the morning of his death with Valentine’s flowers and a stuffed yellow elephant.
Petty’s mother, Kelly, said she loved helping in the kitchen and her short time in the school’s Junior Reserve Officer Training Corps. A member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, she had helped in hurricane recovery the summer before her death.
“She loved her friends, she loved her family, and, most importantly, she loved God,” Kelly Petty said.
Her sister, Meghan, said that while Alaina was the baby of her family’s four children, in some ways she was the oldest, displaying a maturity beyond her years. They would snuggle together to watch television.
“She was an angel on Earth and she should still be here,” she said. She cried as she said she could no longer remember her sister’s voice.
Beigel’s mother, Linda Schulman, and his stepfather, Michael Schulman, talked of his love for teaching, his students and baseball. His mother said he got the job teaching at Stoneman Douglas because he agreed to coach the cross-country team – even though he did not know how.
Speaking in a strong voice, Linda Schulman said he told his runners that if they would teach him about cross-country, he would teach them about life. When his runners just missed qualifying for the state meet, they asked him what they could do next time. She drew laughs when he said he told them, “Run faster.” That remains the team’s motto.
Michael Schulman said that when he told Scott he wanted to marry his mother, he said his only response was, “All I ask is that you make my mother happy.”
Cruz, 23, pleaded guilty to 17 counts of first-degree murder in October, meaning the jury will decide only whether he is sentenced to death or life without parole.
The jurors saw Monday the three cellphone videos he made starting six days before his attack.
In the first two, he is not seen. Only his voice is heard.
“Today is the day. Today it all begins. The day of my massacre shall begin,” he said in the first. In the second, he says, “When you see me on the news, you’ll all know who I am. You’re all going to die. … Can’t wait.”
In the final video, taken three days before the shooting, Cruz, wearing a ball cap, talks into the camera and says he is “going to be the next school shooter of 2018.” He ends the video by making gun noises.
In text messages, starting about 90 minutes before the attack, Cruz tells his ex-girlfriend he loves her and then asks “Do you want me to go away?”
She replied, “You’re scaring me and I want you to leave me alone.” She told him she had a boyfriend. He replied he didn’t care. As he arrived at the school, he texted her once more he loved her.
Meanwhile, a friend he had spent several hours texting with about possibly getting him a date that night, also responded that he had found a girl who would hang out with him. That text also arrived as Cruz was arriving at the school.
“Too late man,” Cruz responded. Three minutes later, the attack began.
When jurors get the case, they will vote 17 times, once for each of the victims, on whether to recommend capital punishment.
For each death sentence, the jury must be unanimous or the sentence for that victim is life. The jurors are told that to vote for death, the prosecution’s aggravating circumstances for that victim must, in their judgment, “outweigh” the defense’s mitigators. A juror can also vote for life out of mercy for Cruz. During jury selection, the panelists said under oath that they are capable of voting for either sentence.